CAN WE BE SURE OF ANYTHING ?
When I first read that text from McCartneys Auctions, it was rather significant .
As a member of Chess Collectors International, I have axcess to research by collectors going back to the mid 1980's.
The founding members who did this work, might even claim it goes back even further .
Yet even today we need more information to fill the blanks, so the claim by McCartneys is as valid now in 2011,
as it was then in 1988.
I accept evidence as proof if it is proven, but claims by any reputed experts regardless of their stature, is very contestable, and so it should be, if all they offer is their word .
If we accept the " word evidence " from one party but not another, then we might as well accept it from every Tom Dick and Harry .
Research work on chessmen is ongoing, and change is necessary as new evidence appears, the better the original research, the less likely such evidence found will be of major significance.
However even the best work will always be improved upon .
Jun 20, 2036
Photos: 6